Avoid a demonstrated CMOC -O2 removed-index-reload error with independent calibration and position pointers. Keep established joystick readiness across menus, stabilize shared fire/keyboard scans, and protect input sampling from IRQ interference. Ship pristine QUADPSL04.DSK. Native right-port emulated analog/button checks pass for both directions, four lasting T-piece turns, and steering after keyboard resume. Host input/store/rules/video regressions and unchanged memory guards pass. Preserve personal score disks and record physical/128 KB/audio limits.
141 lines
8.1 KiB
Markdown
141 lines
8.1 KiB
Markdown
# Audio routing correction — November 10, 2026
|
|
|
|
Brian reported constant noise during keyboard play, including while idle. That
|
|
is outside the specification: sound should consist of brief event effects with
|
|
silence between them. His earlier pacing feedback remains keyboard evidence;
|
|
physical joystick testing is still pending.
|
|
|
|
## Correction
|
|
|
|
The old code initialized CardGame audio once at startup, then continuously called
|
|
`readJoystickPositions`. The public CMOC documentation explicitly states that
|
|
analog sound routing shares hardware with joystick measurements. The permitted
|
|
CardGame example's initSound.c selects the DAC and enables sound; beep.c does not
|
|
close that path on return. This leaves audio routing unmanaged between events.
|
|
|
|
The game now calls the documented `Player_disableSound()` helper before joystick
|
|
sampling and at startup. Each enabled effect calls `initSound()` immediately
|
|
before `beep()` and `Player_disableSound()` immediately afterward. This keeps the
|
|
speaker path closed while idle and while the joystick selector is being changed.
|
|
|
|
The implementation uses standard CardGame and bsound APIs only. It installs no
|
|
Player IRQ, supplies no custom interrupt/sound driver, and adds no direct hardware
|
|
access. The quiet movement volume and existing event pitches/durations are kept.
|
|
The half-frequency constants are the same values the previous code obtained by
|
|
integer division; gameplay timing, scoring and save format are unchanged.
|
|
|
|
Public references read through the installed MCP manual:
|
|
|
|
- `programming-in-c/api.html#api-player-disablesound`: analog-path enable/disable
|
|
shares hardware with joystick measurements; link bsound.
|
|
- `programming-in-c/api.html#api-beep` and public cardgame.h: initialization,
|
|
positive period/duration and bounded volume.
|
|
- Public Player.h: standalone enable/disable helpers; Player_init/shutdown are
|
|
associated with the optional player/IRQ service, which this game does not use.
|
|
- Pierre Sarrazin's local CardGame 0.1.15 initSound.c/beep.c (public-domain
|
|
examples) were read for reference. No assembly or register code was copied.
|
|
|
|
## Actual MCP captures
|
|
|
|
Official VCC Plus 3.5.5 (48), disposable CoCo 3 / 512 KB workers, stock fast mode.
|
|
Each WAV captures 120 emulated fields directly, at 44,100 Hz, PCM16 stereo,
|
|
88,651 or 88,652 sample frames. Both channels were checked.
|
|
|
|
| Context | Result |
|
|
| --- | --- |
|
|
| MC6809 title idle | Every sample zero |
|
|
| MC6809 gameplay idle | Every sample zero in the captured no-event window |
|
|
| MC6809 right-move action window | Short effect, peak 1,792 in each channel; 10 changing edges; last 500 ms exactly zero |
|
|
| MC6809 idle after movement | Every sample zero |
|
|
| MC6809 hard-drop/lock window | Short effect, peak 5,120 in each channel; 10 changing edges; last 500 ms exactly zero |
|
|
| MC6809 pause menu idle | Every sample zero |
|
|
| MC6809 Sound OFF, following a left-key action | Every sample zero; OFF was also verified on the guest settings screen |
|
|
| MC6809 Sound OFF idle | Every sample zero |
|
|
| HD6309 gameplay idle, reset emulation mode | Every sample zero |
|
|
| HD6309 right-move action window | Short effect, peak 1,792 in each channel; 10 changing edges; last 500 ms exactly zero |
|
|
|
|
The movement peak is lower than the landing peak, preserving relative volume.
|
|
Positive effect captures establish that silent windows are not simply a globally
|
|
muted capture endpoint. Captures start after bounded input, so a silent post-key
|
|
window alone does not establish whether an earlier very short effect played.
|
|
|
|
The unchanged baseline disk was also captured. Its sampled idle and post-movement
|
|
windows were zero. **The reported continuous noise was not reproduced in the
|
|
isolated worker.** The routing defect was corrected from the public contracts
|
|
and source usage; confirmation that Brian's actual-app idle noise is gone still
|
|
requires retesting that environment. These are direct guest PCM checks, not a
|
|
claim of human listening, Mac output-device qualification or a 128 KB pass.
|
|
|
|
`tools/check_audio.py` checks all PCM channels for exact digital silence, or for
|
|
a nonconstant effect with a silent final 500 ms. Example:
|
|
|
|
```sh
|
|
python3 tools/check_audio.py test-output/audio/after-idle-game.wav --expect silent
|
|
python3 tools/check_audio.py test-output/audio/after-lock-effect.wav --expect effect
|
|
```
|
|
|
|
Raw WAVs and full receipts remain in ignored test-output/audio/. The MCP baseline
|
|
used a freshly built disposable disk. The pre-update local writable image also
|
|
contained QPSAVE0.DAT/QPSAVE1.DAT; that original is preserved under ignored
|
|
local-media-backups/. A second private copy there replaces only QUAD.BIN with
|
|
the corrected executable. Every other file and the DOS boot track were verified
|
|
byte-identical. These personal save files are excluded from Git and MCP inputs.
|
|
The personal emulator session was not operated or reset.
|
|
|
|
## Build identity
|
|
|
|
- Project revision 16, Release, build `CFC0A2F2-9247-4B1C-9CF8-8CC1AFE896B6`.
|
|
- Artifact `261716EE-81C8-487D-A7BF-E5C9F51BC044`.
|
|
- Binary: 26,370 bytes, SHA-256
|
|
`5c9f3be05fde79e09a5a583740e676f2fb06eddc136dd9d419f62f12da6bebfe`.
|
|
- Pristine Quadrapassel.DSK: 161,280 bytes, SHA-256
|
|
`d23bc2a1aa60970becaf7ff8be064efc8ea47a5043adf9661d9a6c22bcedfd9b`.
|
|
- Code/constants end $7AE8; static data end $1318; existing memory checks passed.
|
|
- MC6809 run `0B67B031-7CEE-4CD7-98CA-649B295FECB3`.
|
|
- HD6309 run `356B3452-D3AA-4EBA-8111-1D41EC9F9277`.
|
|
- All owned runs are stopped. No implementation commit or push was requested.
|
|
|
|
## November 11 — normal-window buzz still reported
|
|
|
|
Brian confirmed the font candidate buzzes on its title screen before Start,
|
|
including after quitting/reopening VCC Plus. The real 512 KB CoCo 3 does not
|
|
buzz. During the authorized desktop check, pausing VCC Plus stopped the noise;
|
|
Run was then restored without resetting the game or replacing mounted media.
|
|
This establishes a normal-window playback symptom, not its cause.
|
|
|
|
The visible normal setup is MC6809/512 KB at 1x, with an FD-502/floppy controller,
|
|
Speech/Sound Cartridge, Orchestra-90 and a stopped Hello World cassette. App
|
|
sound is enabled at 50%. Those peripherals differ from the supported disposable
|
|
worker; their presence alone does not establish that any cartridge causes the
|
|
buzz. The public MCP audio tool captures only the disposable worker, not the
|
|
normal window or microphone. No claim of hearing the actual speaker is made.
|
|
|
|
The new standard candidate reasserts Player_disableSound after joystick button/
|
|
position sampling as well as before it. This is a defensive public-library
|
|
change, not a demonstrated cure. It adds no custom audio code or hardware access.
|
|
Official build 51, project revision 2, run
|
|
`0174149F-48E6-4EB6-8D96-BC1BF0BF4C87`: title and gameplay idle captures are
|
|
zero in both channels; movement peak 1792 in both channels, nine changing edges,
|
|
last 500 ms zero. Each direct stereo capture covers 120 fields; the effect
|
|
capture contains 88,651 frames, idle captures 88,652 at 44,100 Hz. Checks pass.
|
|
Owned runs are stopped. The normal-window buzz remains unconfirmed fixed and
|
|
needs the new candidate retested in that same environment. Full final identity
|
|
and preserved-score disk are in TITLE_AND_SCORING_UPDATE.md.
|
|
|
|
Build 02 changes keyboard/joystick logical handling, not sound APIs. Official
|
|
build-53 MC6809/512 KB idle capture remains zero; the positive movement capture
|
|
has both-channel peak 7936, ten changing edges and silent final 500 ms. These
|
|
120-field captures pass the existing checker. The user-reported normal-window
|
|
buzz was still present on build 01 and remains open pending build-02 retest;
|
|
the differing emulator versions prevent treating effect peak changes as a
|
|
controlled game-volume comparison. See JOYSTICK_FIX.md for the current artifact.
|
|
|
|
Build 03, official build 53 / revision 3 / MC6809 / 512 KB: title and gameplay
|
|
idle are exactly zero in both channels. Movement peak 7936 in each channel,
|
|
21 changing edges, final 500 ms zero; 120-field captures pass the checker.
|
|
This remains isolated-worker evidence and does not close the normal-window buzz.
|
|
|
|
Build04 changes only argument addressing after the build03 checks; its final
|
|
native analog checks did not recapture audio. Do not label build03's exact PCM
|
|
numbers as measured build04 results. The normal-window speaker buzz stays open.
|